A Game of Brinkmanship?

Date:

71pVdueAgZL | BookStore from Narratives Magazine

The book Nuclear Deterrence and Conflict Management between India and Pakistan, written by Dr. Zia ul Haq Shamsi, is a disruptive book on the nuclear deterrence challenges faced by Pakistan, with particular emphasis on the possible avenues for conflict resolution between the two adversaries.

Dr. Shamsi is ideally placed to write on the subject; he has served as an instructor at various defence colleges in Pakistan, particularly in the field of national security and peace.

Enumerating a long list of crises situations and wars with India, the author argues that the Rann of Kutch, Sir Creek and Siachen are, perhaps, the most tractable issues which are ripe for conflict resolution between the two states.

While the initial two chapters outline the genesis of the conflict between the states, the third covers the periods of stability, followed by a deterioration in relations between 1983-98. The book states that an era before they went nuclear, there could have been a year of rapprochement for the two states, following a decade of lost opportunity ­— but it was not to be.   

The following chapter is dedicated to the Kargil conflict in 1999 and its after-effects. It is a critical review of the conflagration and how the region was taken to the brink. Brigadier Qadir goes on to discuss the manner in which this conflict tested the efficacy of nuclear deterrence between two nuclear armed states, against the backdrop of simmering disputes. The post 9/11 environment and rapprochement is the subject of Chapter 5, which deals with a different set of crises that emerged between India and Pakistan as a result. It includes the 2001 attack on the Indian Parliament that led to a year-long stand-off between the two opposing armies. It was followed by a great deal of introspection, and a review of the respective strategic doctrines.

Chapter 6 is a discussion on the efficacy of nuclear weapons in reducing the incidence of conflicts between the two countries; it examines the role of nuclear deterrence in conflicts and crises. The next chapter tests the P2 (Possibility-Probability) model against conflicts like Operation Gibraltar (1965), the Cuban Missile Crisis (1962) and finally, the Kargil Conflict (1999), with a view to build future scenarios and suggest a way forward. Taking the debate further, Chapter 8 deals with the post-Pulwama environment, as the danger of a nuclear war between India and Pakistan grows by the day, albeit as a consequence of the Indian leadership’s thoughtless brinkmanship. In the concluding chapter lies the heart of the book. The author says, “opportunities must be explored in difficulties, and opportunities multiply as they are seized.” The probability of future wars between the two, based on whether there is a depletion or perceptual dilution of the nuclear deterrence, are determined against possibilities of peace. Dr. Shamsi concludes with validation of the P2 model and emphasises a peaceful resolution of all outstanding disputes.

The book is a valuable addition to the literature on the subject of nuclear deterrence and the challenges faced by South Asia, and has significant instructive value. The addition of the P2 Model is perhaps a unique creation of the author, which merits a read.

Brig R Mehboob Qadir | BookStore from Narratives Magazine
Brig (R) Mehboob Qadir
The writer is Director, Forum for Middle East and Africa (FAME), SASSI University.

Brig (R) Mehboob Qadir
Brig (R) Mehboob Qadirhttp://narratives.com.pk
The writer is Director, Forum for Middle East and Africa (FAME), SASSI University.
Previous article
Next article

111 COMMENTS

  1. Hello to evеry body, it’s my first visit of thiѕ
    blog; this webѕite іncludes awesome and really good information for readers.

  2. I һave been surfing online more tһan 4 hours today, yet I
    never found any іnteresting artiϲle like yours.
    It’s pretty worth enough for me. Personally, if all
    web owners and bloggers maɗe gоod content as you did, the net
    will be much more usefuⅼ than evеr before.

  3. I haᴠe been exploring for a little f᧐r any high-quality articles
    or blog posts օn this sort of house . Exploring in Yahoo I
    at last stumbⅼed upon this web site. Reading this
    informatiօn So i am satisfied to exⲣress that Ι’ve
    a very juѕt right uncanny feeling I came upon exactly wһat
    I needed. I most unquestionably will make sure to don?t
    omit tһis web site and giѵe it a glance regularly.

  4. Woɑh! I’m really enjoying the template/theme of this site.
    It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s very hard to get that “perfect balance”
    between superb usability and visual ɑppeal. I must say you’ve done
    а excelⅼent ϳob with this. In addition, the blog loads super quick for me on Firefox.

    Excellent Blog!

  5. Greetings from Ꮯalifοrnia! I’m bored to death at work
    so I ԁecided to check out your website on my iphone during
    lunch break. I really like the knowⅼedge you present here and cɑn’t wait to take a look when I get home.

    I’m shocked at how fast your bⅼog loaded on my phone ..
    I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyһow, superb blog!

  6. whoah thiѕ blog іs fantastіc i love studying your aгticⅼeѕ.
    Stay up the good work! You recognize, lots of individuals are searcһing round for
    this info, ʏou can aid them greatly.

Comments are closed.

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

The Burden of Telling the Truth

Here I discharge my burden of telling the truth: if some bloated egos are more important than the state, there would be no remedy

Two Lost Decades of Pakistan Economy 2002 – 2022

During the last two decades, all the relevant parties have ruled this country, including the establishment, but they all failed to deliver

The Umbilical Cord

The United States remains the last fallback for Pakistan in times of every economic crisis

Occupied Kashmir Bleeds

Although the precarious food and economic situation of Pakistan is understandable, sacrifices made by Kashmiris should not be bartered for onions and tomatoes