Pakistan’s Choices Amid Global Isolation & Economic Fragmentation


Growing trade restrictions may reverse economic integration and undermine the cooperation needed to protect against new shocks and address global challenges.

The global economic stage is undergoing a profound transformation, with a rising specter of geo-economic fragmentation threatening to cleave the world economy into rival blocs. This disintegration not only spells a precarious outlook for the global economies but also holds significant implications for Pakistan’s economic landscape. As the International Monetary Fund (IMF) sounds the alarm bells on the perils of fragmentation, the urgent need for enhanced global collaboration comes into sharp focus.

Estimates of the potential costs of fragmentation are marked by their variability, painting a spectrum of possible outcomes. Should trade fragmentation gain momentum, the impact could range from a modest 0.2 percent reduction in global output in a limited fragmentation scenario to a staggering 7.0 percent decrease or about $7.4 trillion in today’s dollars in a severe scenario. That’s equivalent to the combined size of the French and German economies, and three times sub-Saharan Africa’s annual output. However, the repercussions do not stop there. The advent of technological decoupling could exacerbate the economic toll. If technological decoupling is added to the mix, some countries could see losses of up to 12 percent of the GDP. The effects of fragmentation ripple through various channels, from the imposition of trade barriers to the constriction of technological diffusion, and from the curtailment of cross-border migration to the diminishing flow of capital, all while international cooperation faces a sharp decline.

The IMF has emerged as a steadfast advocate for heightened global cooperation as an antidote to the fragmentary forces that threaten economies worldwide. Emphasizing the need for unity, the IMF champions the role of multilateral institutions in recalibrating global collaboration and staunching the tide of fragmentation. Its arsenal of financial tools, coupled with its impartial approach and global oversight mechanisms, enables the IMF to serve as a linchpin in guiding nations toward a more cooperative future.

Kristalina Georgieva, the Managing Director for the International Monitory Fund has advised the world leaders, including Pakistan, “Policymakers need to focus on the issues that matter most not only to the wealth of nations but also to the economic well-being of ordinary people.” Georgieva wrote in the Foreign Affairs Magazine, “They must nurture the bonds of trust among countries wherever possible so they can quickly step-up cooperation when the next major shock comes.”

The trajectory toward geo-economic fragmentation charts a profound challenge, one whose reverberations transcend international boundaries and cast a shadow over economic outlooks. Nevertheless, the power of collective action remains an indomitable force. Countries, including Pakistan, stand at a crossroads where mutual engagement can pave the way for concerted efforts to counteract fragmentation’s onslaught. By forging alliances that rise above national confines and coalescing around shared imperatives, nations can begin the arduous task of mitigating fragmentation’s corrosive effects and fortifying the pillars of global cooperation.

In Pakistan’s context, the urgency of the situation cannot be overstated. As a country that’s intricately linked to the global economic fabric, Pakistan finds itself at the nexus of both challenges and opportunities. It’s imperative for policymakers and stakeholders alike to heed the IMF’s call and prioritize cooperation that transcends borders. A concerted push for comprehensive reforms that bolster economic resilience and galvanize cooperation is essential to steer Pakistan away from the precipice of fragmentation-induced vulnerability.

image | Balance Sheet, Daily Narratives, Featured from Narratives Magazine

The world, once a tapestry of interconnected economies, is undergoing a seismic transformation. The ominous shadow of geo-economic fragmentation looms, threatening to carve the global economy into rival blocks. For Pakistan, a nation straddling the delicate balance between challenges and opportunities, charting a course through these turbulent waters demands a strategic and comprehensive approach.

As the IMF sounds the alarm on the far-reaching risks of fragmentation, Pakistan finds itself at a crossroads that demands visionary leadership, collaboration, and a steadfast commitment to resilience.

At the heart of this dilemma lies the undeniable truth, the world’s economies are increasingly vulnerable to isolation. Trade barriers and protectionist policies, once distant whispers, now reverberate across nations, affecting even the farthest corners of the globe. Pakistan’s response must be rooted in the diversification of its partners and offers. By forging new trade partnerships and broadening its economic horizons, Pakistan can shield itself from the potentially crippling impacts of isolation.

Yet, trade is only one facet of the challenge. Technological decoupling — the act of severing technological interdependence — casts its own shadow. Here, the key lies in investment in innovation, research, and development. A nation that adapts to the changing tides of innovation can remain afloat in a sea of uncertainty.

But the waters run deeper still. Migration, once a bridge for the exchange of skills and ideas, faces the risk of constriction. Pakistan must champion the facilitation of cross-border movement, acknowledging the immense potential in harnessing the talents of its diaspora while welcoming the expertise of foreign workers.

In the midst of these challenges, the IMF gestures, waving the banner of cooperation. Its call is not just a plea for unity, but a lifeline for nations navigating these uncharted waters. Multilateral institutions, like the IMF, offer a platform for collective action, for the pooling of resources, and for a united stance against fragmentation. The IMF’s tools and expertise, from financial instruments to global oversight mechanisms, can pave Pakistan’s path to stability.

Yet, Pakistan’s journey is not a lonely one. As a member of the global community, Pakistan’s actions resonate far beyond its borders. Strengthening regional integration through initiatives like the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) can shield the nation from the worst effects of fragmentation. By nurturing international partnerships and engaging in diplomatic dialogues, Pakistan can be an advocate for collective solutions on the global stage.

As the tapestry of the world economy unravels, Pakistan must rewrite its role in this narrative. It requires visionary leadership that defies isolation, embraces innovation, and champions collaboration. It calls for policies that create an attractive investment climate, a resilient financial sector, and an educated workforce capable of thriving in a swiftly changing landscape.

In the end, the story of Pakistan’s journey through geo-economic fragmentation is not one of despair, but of determination. It’s a tale of resilience in the face of uncertainty, of unity in the face of isolation, and of progress in the face of disruption. As the waves of change crash upon its shores, Pakistan has the opportunity to emerge not as a victim of fragmentation, but as a beacon of cooperation, a model for navigating the complexities of a fractured world.

In the broader spectrum, the vision of a cohesive global economy, standing firm against the onslaught of fragmentation, remains within reach. It requires the unwavering commitment of nations to look beyond immediate interests and work collaboratively to foster a landscape of stability and prosperity. In this shared pursuit, Pakistan stands as a testament to the power of unified action and serves as a beacon of hope in a world teetering on the edge of fragmentation

Amir Jahangir
Amir Jahangir
The writer is a global competitiveness, risk, and development expert. He leads Mishal Pakistan, the country partner institute of the Centre for the New Economy and Society Platform at the World Economic Forum.

Share post:



More like this

IMF’s Global GDP Outlook ’23: Pakistan Responds

Amidst the unfolding global economic shifts, Pakistan's response must be grounded in pragmatism and resilience. Crafting a pragmatic roadmap involves embracing regional cooperation, enhancing domestic competitiveness, and fostering investor confidence.

20 Reasons to Love or Hate Ishaq Dar as Finance Minister

Finance Minister Ishaq Dar, who delivered the Budget 2022-23...

PDM Govt’s FY23 Economic Scorecard the Worst in Pakistan’s History

Critics say that no economic plan is likely to work until the country first puts an end to the political instability

Our focus should be the economy, but the PTI and the PDM are talking about everything else.

“Our focus should be the economy, but the PTI and the PDM are talking about everything else.”